Investing

MYGA vs. CD Rates in 2026 — Which Actually Wins?

Author

Michael McMillan

May 20, 2026

In 2026, guaranteed yields are finally looking good again. But if you only look at the top-line rate, you could miss out on thousands of dollars over five years. When you compare MYGAs and CDs for your safe money, there is more to the story than just the rate.

A certificate of deposit (CD) is a bank product that locks your money at a fixed rate for a set term and is insured by the FDIC. A multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) is an insurance contract that does the same thing, but with a higher guaranteed rate, tax-deferred growth, and a different safety structure.

This guide breaks it down simply. We’ll look at rates, taxes, access to your money, and how safe your principal is, so you can decide what works best for your retirement.

2026 Rate Comparison: 5-Year CD vs. 5-Year MYGA
Feature	5-Year Bank CD	5-Year MYGA
Best Available Rate (May 2026)	~4.34% to 4.40%	~5.90% to 6.30%
Rate Premium	Baseline	~1.50% to 2.00% higher
Tax Treatment	Taxable annually (1099-INT)	Tax-deferred until withdrawal
Annual Liquidity	Penalty applies (3–12 months interest)	Up to 10% penalty-free per year
Principal Protection	FDIC/NCUA up to $250,000	State Guaranty Association + carrier strength
IRS Early Withdrawal Penalty	None	10% if under age 59½
Health Crisis Waiver	Not available	Available on most contracts
Probate Treatment	Goes through estate	Passes directly to named beneficiary

‍Sources: Bankrate (CD rates, May 2026); CANNEX (MYGA rates, May 2026)

‍

Behind the Curtain: Why MYGAs Pay 1.50% to 2.00% More

In May 2026, the best 5-year CDs pay about 4.34% to 4.40%. Top 5-year MYGAs pay around 5.90% to 6.30%. This difference is real and comes from how banks and insurance companies invest your money.

Banks have to keep a lot of cash on hand, so they invest CD funds in short-term, lower-yield investments. Insurance companies play by different rules. They invest MYGA money in longer-term, higher-yield bonds. Since their timeline matches your contract, they can offer you a higher guaranteed rate.

Here’s a simple example. A retired couple puts $200,000 into a 5-year CD at 4.40%. After five years, they have about $248,000 before taxes. If they put the same $200,000 into a 5-year MYGA at 6.10%, they end up with about $268,500. And with tax deferral, the difference gets even bigger.

The “Tax Drag” Effect: Why the Math Favors Tax Deferral

One of the most overlooked costs of a CD is what financial professionals call "tax drag." Banks report your CD interest to the IRS each year via Form 1099-INT, even if you leave every dollar in the account. You owe ordinary income tax on that interest annually, which pulls money out of the compounding cycle.

With a MYGA, your money grows tax-deferred. You don’t pay taxes each year; you only pay when you take money out.

Let’s look at how taxes affect a $100,000 investment over five years:

CD at 4.40% (24% tax bracket): You earn approximately $24,000 in interest, but you pay roughly $5,760 in taxes along the way. Your after-tax gain is closer to $18,240.
MYGA at 6.10% (24% tax bracket): You earn approximately $34,500 in interest with no annual tax. If you withdraw at the end of the term and pay tax, then your after-tax gain is approximately $26,220.
The difference: In this scenario, the MYGA delivers roughly $7,980 more in after-tax wealth from the same starting amount, before accounting for any rate premium.

If you’re in a higher tax bracket, the gap gets even bigger. Tax deferral is a real advantage if you don’t need to spend the interest every year.

Liquidity Myths, Health Crises, and Early Access

People often worry about withdrawing their money from a MYGA. That’s a fair concern, but the details matter.

Standard early withdrawal penalties differ between the two products:

If you withdraw money from a CD early, you usually lose 3 to 12 months of interest. That might not sound like much, but it interrupts your compounding.
MYGAs have surrender charges if you take out all your money early. These charges start high and go down each year. For example, a 7-year MYGA might charge 8% in the first year and only 1% in the seventh year.

However, most MYGAs include a 10% annual free withdrawal provision. You can withdraw up to 10% of your account value each year with no surrender charge. For a $200,000 MYGA, that is $20,000 per year of accessible cash, structured liquidity that most retirees find more than adequate.

One important warning for younger savers: withdrawing MYGA interest before age 59½ triggers a 10% IRS early withdrawal penalty on the gain, in addition to ordinary income tax. This penalty does not apply to CDs. If you are younger than 55 and still building wealth, a CD may be the more appropriate vehicle for this reason alone.

Where MYGAs genuinely outperform CDs is in health crisis provisions. Many MYGA contracts include terminal illness and nursing home confinement waivers that eliminate all surrender charges if you or your spouse faces a qualifying health event. Most bank CDs offer no equivalent relief.

Safety Check: FDIC vs. State Guaranty Associations

A lot of people trust FDIC insurance the most. It covers up to $250,000 per person, per bank, and is backed by the federal government. That’s why CDs help people sleep at night.

MYGAs rely on a different, yet robust, framework. First, they depend on the issuing insurance carrier's claims-paying ability. This is why carriers are rated by independent agencies (AM Best, S&P, Moody’s), and why you should only place premiums with carriers holding an A rating or better. Second, every state maintains a State Guaranty Association that provides a backstop if a carrier becomes insolvent. Coverage limits typically range from $100,000 to $300,000, depending on the state, and most states cover at least $250,000 in annuity contract value.

If you’re putting in a large amount, here’s what to do:

Keep each MYGA under your state’s coverage limit. For example, if you have $500,000, split it between two or more A-rated companies, keeping each contract under the limit.
Verify your state's specific coverage limit at the National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations (NOLHGA) before purchasing.
Check the carrier's AM Best rating independently and select those with an A (Excellent) rating or better. Many online platforms display these ratings in real time.

Expert Strategies: The 3-Year Rule, Laddering, and Legacy

Experienced advisors use a simple heuristic when helping clients choose between CDs and MYGAs: the 3-Year Rule. Money needed within three years belongs in CDs, high-yield savings accounts, or short-term Treasuries. For money with a three-year-or-longer horizon, MYGAs historically deliver superior risk-adjusted after-tax returns.

The MYGA ladder is a smart move for retirees who want steady access to cash and higher yields. Instead of putting all your money in one term, you split it across several:

One-third in a 3-year MYGA (currently approximately 5.50% to 5.80%)
One-third in a 5-year MYGA (currently approximately 5.90% to 6.30%)
One-third in a 7-year MYGA (currently approximately 5.60% to 6.00%)

This works like a CD ladder, but with higher rates and tax deferral. When each MYGA matures, you can withdraw the money, reinvest it, or convert it into guaranteed income.

When a MYGA matures, you have a powerful option unavailable to CD holders: the 1035 exchange. Under IRS Section 1035, you can roll a maturing MYGA directly into a new annuity contract without triggering a taxable event. This legally defers your tax bill indefinitely and is one of the most underutilized tools in retirement income planning.

Also, think about what happens when you pass away. CDs usually go through your estate and may be subject to probate. MYGAs go straight to your named beneficiaries, skipping probate. Your heirs will pay income tax on the gains when they receive the money, but good planning can help reduce this tax.

The Ultimate Decision Framework: Which Is Right for You?

Choosing between a CD and a MYGA isn’t about which one is best overall. It’s about what fits your timeline, tax bracket, and goals.

Choose a CD if:

You are under age 59½ and may need the funds before retirement age.
Your deposit is under $10,000, and the simplicity of a bank account matters to you.
You need the psychological certainty of FDIC federal backing.
You have a very specific, short-term cash need with a defined date, such as a home purchase within 12 months.

Choose a MYGA if:

You have a 3-year or more time horizon with no expected need for the full principal.
You are in a tax bracket of 22% or higher and want to reduce your annual taxable income.
You want to maximize your guaranteed yield from a principal-protected, fixed-rate vehicle.
You plan to convert the funds into guaranteed lifetime income at maturity, taking advantage of the MYGA-to-income annuity conversion option.
You want your assets to pass directly to a named beneficiary, bypassing probate.

For many retirees, the best answer is to use both. Keep some money in CDs for easy access, and put the rest in MYGAs to earn more over time. You don’t have to pick just one.

How Annuities.net Can Help Insurance Agents Grow

If you’re an insurance agent, explaining the MYGA vs CD choice is one of the most valuable talks you can have with clients. The right tools make it easier and more convincing.

Annuities.net gives agents access to:

Live, multi-carrier rate feeds: Compare real-time MYGA rates across dozens of A-rated carriers instantly, so you can always show clients the highest contractual guarantees available in the market today.
Custom calculators: Show clients the real difference between CD taxes and MYGA tax deferral with clear, interactive visuals. This sustains the conversation focused on facts, not opinions.
State-specific guidance: Quickly check guarantee limits, suitability rules, and licensing requirements for your state—no need to dig through paperwork.
Educational resources: Give clients clear, unbiased info so you come across as a helpful guide, not just a salesperson. This builds trust and helps clients make decisions faster.

The best agents use the MYGA vs. CD comparison to help clients explore options, not as a sales pitch. When clients see the numbers, they usually decide on their own.

Bottom Line: The Numbers Do Not Lie

In the current rate environment, MYGA vs CD rates in 2026 are not a close call for most retirement savers. The rate advantage of 1.50% to 2.00%, combined with the compounding power of tax deferral, typically delivers thousands of dollars in additional after-tax wealth over a 5-year term. Add the 10% annual free withdrawal provision, health crisis waivers, and probate-free transfer to beneficiaries, and the MYGA looks even stronger.

CDs are still best for short-term needs, younger savers who might need their money before age 59½, or anyone who insists on FDIC backing. But if you’re retired, have a longer timeline, and want to save on taxes, MYGAs are likely to work harder for you in 2026.

Want to see today’s MYGA rates from more than 45 top-rated companies? Check rates now at Annuities.net and see how much your money can earn.

Compare Rates From 45+ Carriers — Free!

View Current MYGA Rates

‍

Is an annuity right for you?

Select the annuity that fits your financial plan. No pressure, always transparent.